Is it really the end of membership as we know it?
Sarah Sladek’s book
"The End of Membership As We Know It" has generated a lot of attention.
And with good reason. The chief executives of membership organizations and their directors
are concerned that the 2008-2009 downturn is not over. Although member numbers and revenues
are improving, it’s happening more slowly than we hoped or planned for and this is putting
strain on our resources.
Zzeem conducted the second annual survey of Canadian membership organizations in the first
quarter of 2012. The numbers tell an interesting story.
Members are no longer renewing their membership just because they always have. They’re assessing
the member value proposition to find out if they are really getting value. Those who do renew are
often less engaged that they were in previous years. It’s harder to find the time and the budget
to attend conferences.
With fewer attendees it’s harder to make a successful pitch to sponsors. And they have troubles
of their own. Many sponsors have pulled back or out of events that they have sponsored for years.
Although we seem to be through the trough in revenues it’s taking organizations longer than
expected for revenue to return to “normal” levels.
Some organizations will not survive because they do not have the financial reserves to get
through this. The membership organizations that will survive and thrive are those who have
a compelling and well-articulated value proposition to their members – and to their sponsors.
2012 Benchmark Survey for Membership Organizations
By membership organizations we mean non-for-profit entities who have dues-paying members and whose
primary activity is providing services to those members.
This is a specialized niche within the not-for-profit sector with its own unique characteristics.
Membership organizations are typically self-sustaining, and cannot rely on government assistance
Just like service companies in the for profit sector, they need to provide value to the people
that they serve or they will not survive.
A membership organization is a business and must be run as one to be sustainable.
There is very little data available for the membership organization niche. The purpose of this
survey is to help to fill that void and to provide the sector with critical information about
their peers and their competitors.
The respondents were either Canadian organizations or the Canadian arms of international
The membership organizations surveyed included entities of all sizes. Respondents’ annual revenue
ranged from less than $10,000 to more than $20 million.
As was the case last year, the majority of the respondents are federally incorporated not-for-profit
Respondents included organizations whose members are primarily individuals, and those whose members
are primarily corporate. The respondents were almost evenly split between these two types of
THIS IS A DANGER ZONE...
80% of respondents have financial reserves but most have only enough reserves to cover a few
months of operating expenses. A single deficit year could force a shut-down of the
There has been little improvement from last year in the level of financial reserves held by
respondents. However, respondents seem more aware that this is a danger than they did last year.
This may be because more organizations used their reserves last year and about 15% of these plan
to use their reserves again this year.
WE'RE LESS OPTIMISTIC...
Last year, 80% of respondents expected that they would have more members in the current year.
This year only 60% of respondents expect higher member numbers.
Value Proposition to Members
WE'RE GETTING BETTER...
Last year, only a third of respondents were highly confident that their board members could
clearly articulate their member value proposition to a prospective member. This year, the
percentage rose to 47%.
This is still very low. Directors are typically amongst the most well-informed members.
If they don’t know the value proposition well enough to convince a prospective member,
then who does?
WE’RE LESS OPTIMISTIC...
Last year, about 60% of respondents expected their sponsorship revenue to increase.
This year about 70% expect to see an increase.
Value Proposition to Sponsors
WE'RE NOT SELLING IT WELL...
Fewer than 20% of organizations surveyed were highly confident that their board members
could clearly state their value proposition to a prospective sponsor and less than a
third have a documented strategy to accomplish their sponsorship goals. Only 11% have a
documented marketing process to retain and attract sponsors.
Staffing and Costs
BUT WE’RE PLANNING TO INCREASE STAFF AND COSTS...
Despite the fact that fewer respondents are expecting membership to increase, more of them are
planning to increase staff and other costs over last year.
Board Efficiency and Engagement
THIS NEEDS WORK...
This year respondents had a more negative view of the level of engagement and efficiency of their
board members. Most respondents have a handful of board members who do the majority of the
board’s work, with the remainder contributing little. Off record responses indicated that more
board members are recruited because they know someone on the nominating committee than because
they have the skills to make a meaningful contribution.
Planning for the Future
WE’RE GETTING BETTER...
Like last year, most of the organizations surveyed have a current strategic plan. But last year a
third of respondents had no implementation plan. This year, 80% of respondents have an
The 2012 Survey tells us that membership organizations are looking to improve business processes
and retain and attract members. Respondents are doing a lot of things right. The focus for this
year is to increase members and revenue.
The really good news is that membership organizations are paying a lot more attention to their
member value proposition and trying to articulate it in a way that resonates with their members.
They are for the most part, aware of the necessity of revenue diversification and of the
necessity of reserves.
The challenge for membership organizations this year is to build the systems they need to retain
and attract members, find the resources to execute them and at the same
time, build up their reserves. Now there’s a challenge.